top of page

Email Marketing Strategy: Improving Conversions with Compelling Calls to Action

Writer's picture: Jenna MillerJenna Miller

In email marketing, your call-to-action (CTA) is the linchpin that determines whether your campaign will succeed or fall flat on its face. A well-constructed CTA not only draws attention but also compels recipients to take the desired action, whether that’s making a purchase, signing up for a newsletter, or engaging with your content. As email marketing services continue to evolve, it’s important for businesses to fine-tune their email marketing strategy, particularly when it comes to the effectiveness of their CTAs.


Why the Call to Action Matters in Email Marketing

Email marketing is all about engagement. Your goal is to build a connection with your audience, deliver value, and ultimately drive conversions. A CTA serves as the bridge between your email’s content and the desired action, guiding recipients from passive reading to active engagement. An effective CTA not only captures attention but also prompts action, making it one of the most critical components of your email marketing strategy.




5 Essential Strategies For Creating Effective CTAs In Your Email Campaigns

1. Clarity is Key

When it comes to CTAs, clarity should be your top priority. If recipients are left guessing about what action to take, your chances of conversion diminish significantly. Here’s how to ensure your CTAs are crystal clear:

  • Be specific: Instead of using generic phrases like "Click here," clearly state what you want the recipient to do. For example, "Download Your Free eBook" or "Register for the Webinar" removes any ambiguity about the next step.

  • Use action verbs: Strong, actionable words like "Download," "Join," "Buy," or "Subscribe" create a sense of urgency and motivate users to take immediate action. Action words can increase conversion rates by up to 121%.

  • Keep it concise: Less is more when it comes to CTAs. A short, direct CTA like "Get Your Free Trial Now" is far more effective than a long-winded message.

    By being specific and direct, you make it easier for recipients to understand what they’ll get by clicking the CTA—and why they should.


2. Create a Sense of Urgency

One of the best ways to encourage immediate action is to create urgency around your offer. Scarcity and time-sensitive messaging can give recipients that extra nudge they need to click. Here's how to do it effectively:

  • Highlight limited-time offers: Let recipients know that they need to act quickly. For example, "Sign Up Before Midnight to Save 20%" signals urgency without being overly pushy. And don't be afraid to go negative. When you phrase a CTA telling people what they will lose out on, you will see an increase in clicks, up to 2x as many! It's called loss aversion. People are more afraid of losing or missing out on something than they are of gaining. So instead of saying they will save 20%, say, "Don't Miss Out—Sign Up Before Midnight to Avoid Losing 20% Off!"

  • Utilize scarcity tactics: Remind recipients of limited availability, like "Only 10 Spots Left!" or "Exclusive Offer for the First 100 Subscribers." This is especially helpful for webinar and event sign-ups!

  • Incorporate countdown timers: Visual cues like countdowns can enhance the urgency of your offer, prompting users to act before time runs out.

Urgency helps break the inertia and makes recipients feel that missing out on your offer would be a mistake.


3. Emphasize the Value


Your CTA should also make it abundantly clear what the recipient stands to gain by taking action. People need to understand the value they’ll receive in exchange for their time or money. Here’s how to communicate value effectively:

  • Highlight benefits: Instead of focusing on features, emphasize the outcomes of taking action. For example, instead of saying "Subscribe to Our Newsletter," say "Get Exclusive Tips That Save You Time & Money."

  • Use powerful language: Words like "Free," "Instant," "Exclusive," or "Save" add excitement and highlight the benefits of clicking the CTA.

  • Personalize the offer: Personalization can take your CTAs to the next level. Use data on past behavior or preferences to tailor your CTAs. For example, "Based on Your Recent Purchase, Get 15% Off Your Next Order" is a personalized and enticing CTA.

When recipients see a clear benefit, they’re more likely to take the action you want.


4. Test and Optimize

An effective email marketing strategy is a dynamic one that continuously evolves. The best way to find out what works is through testing and optimization. Here’s how to improve your CTA performance over time:

  • A/B testing: Try out different CTAs to see which ones resonate most with your audience. Test various elements like wording, color, placement, and even the urgency level to discover what drives the best results.

  • Monitor click-through rates: Track how well your CTAs perform over time. If certain phrases or offers are underperforming, adjust your strategy accordingly.

  • Experiment with placement: Where you place your CTA within your email matters. In some cases, placing the CTA early on in the email can drive higher engagement, while in others, a CTA at the end may be more effective after recipients have absorbed the content.


Continuous testing ensures that your email campaigns remain relevant and effective, improving your chances of conversion with every send.


5. Optimize for Mobile

With 41% of all emails being opened on mobile devices, it’s crucial that your CTAs are mobile-friendly. A poorly optimized CTA can lead to frustration and a high bounce rate. Here are some tips for mobile optimization:

  • Ensure readability: Your CTA should be legible without zooming in or squinting. Use larger fonts and simple, clear language.

  • Create tappable buttons: Instead of relying on text links, use large, easily tappable buttons for CTAs on mobile. This reduces the chance of users missing the link or accidentally clicking the wrong spot.

  • Test across devices: Make sure your email looks great and functions properly on a variety of mobile devices and screen sizes. A mobile-optimized CTA increases the chances of users clicking through.


CTA Examples to Inspire Your Next Campaign

The following examples showcase how small tweaks in CTA language can lead to big results:


Instead of

Try

Click here to learn more

Download Your Free Guide Now

Learn more about our product.

Start My Free Trial Today

Sign up for updates

Get Exclusive Tips Delivered to My Inbox

Buy now

Claim My 20% Discount Today

Contact us for more information

Speak to an Expert Now

Get started

Start My Free 30-Day Trial Now

Request a demo

See Our Solution in Action—Request a Personalized Demo

Learn more

Find Out How You Can Boost Your ROI Today



More Than Just Words: The Importance of Colors and Placement


While the wording of your call-to-action (CTA) is crucial, it’s only part of the equation. The effectiveness of your CTA also depends heavily on its visual presentation, including the colors you choose and where you place it in your email. A well-designed CTA not only grabs attention but also guides recipients toward conversion by making it easy—and appealing—for them to take action.



The Power of Color in CTAs


Colors evoke emotions and can influence decision-making in subtle but powerful ways. The right color choice for your CTA button can make a huge difference in how noticeable and clickable it is. Here are some key points to consider:


  • Use contrasting colors: Your CTA button should stand out from the rest of your email content. Using a contrasting color helps draw attention and makes the button pop. For example, if your email has a white or light background, a bold color like red, orange, or blue can make your CTA more eye-catching.

  • Choose colors that align with your brand: While contrast is important, your CTA button should still fit within your brand’s color palette. This ensures that your email looks cohesive while still drawing attention to the CTA.

  • Psychology of color: Different colors can evoke different emotions. Red is often associated with urgency or excitement, while green can be seen as calming or associated with positive actions like "Go" or "Start." Consider what emotional response you want to elicit from your recipients when choosing the color for your CTA.



CTA Placement: Location Matters


Where you place your CTA within your email can significantly impact its effectiveness. Even the most compelling copy and eye-catching design won’t help if the button is in a spot where it’s easily overlooked. Here are some placement strategies:


  • Above the fold: Placing your CTA at the top of the email (before the reader has to scroll) ensures it’s seen right away. This can be particularly effective for time-sensitive offers or high-priority actions, like signing up for a limited-time webinar or accessing a special discount.

  • After building context: In some cases, placing the CTA after some explanatory content can be more effective. By leading with valuable information, testimonials, or product benefits, you build a case for why the recipient should take action. Then, placing the CTA directly after that information makes it more persuasive.

  • Repeating the CTA: For longer emails, it’s often beneficial to repeat your CTA in multiple places. Having a CTA both above the fold and at the end of the email ensures that users have multiple opportunities to engage with your offer without having to scroll back up.



CTA Size and Design


Along with color and placement, the size and design of your CTA matter. Here’s what to keep in mind:


  • Use large, clickable buttons: Your CTA should be large enough to easily tap on mobile devices, where many users will view your email. A clear, bold button helps avoid accidental taps or missed clicks.

  • Whitespace is your friend: Surrounding your CTA with whitespace helps draw the recipient’s eye to it. A cluttered email with too much text around the CTA can cause it to get lost in the noise.


By optimizing the design and placement of your CTA, you increase the likelihood that recipients will notice and act on it. The combination of compelling language, strategic color choices, and smart placement ensures that your CTA is as effective as possible in driving conversions.


Crafting CTAs That Convert

Creating an effective CTA is an art that can significantly impact your email marketing success. By focusing on clarity, urgency, value, and optimization, you can create CTAs that not only attract attention but also drive conversions.

If you’re looking to take your email marketing services to the next level, remember that your CTA is more than just a button—it’s the gateway to turning interest into action. Start crafting CTAs that speak directly to your audience, and watch your conversions soar.


A person in a blue shirt in front of a red background. She is holding a tablet that has an image of an email envelope on it. Text: Get Expert Help With Your Email Marketing." Button: Contact Emerald

bottom of page